Cosmetic Formulators’ Favorite VC Derivative: Ethyl Ascorbic Acid
Introduction: Why L-Ergothioneine is a Game-Changer in Beauty
L-ergothioneine, a naturally occurring sulfur-containing amino acid, has become a star ingredient in anti-aging and brightening skincare. Found in shiitake mushrooms, oats, and brewer’s yeast, L-Ergothioneine is clinically proven to:
- Neutralize free radicals 1,000x fasterthan vitamin C (Journal of Cosmetic Science, 2022).
- Reduce UV-induced DNA damage and hyperpigmentation.
- Strengthen skin barriers by upregulating ceramide synthesis (Nature’s Beauty Lab, 2023).
However, L-ergothioneine’s unstable nature in formulations poses challenges. This guide breaks down key considerations to balance efficacy and stability.
Key Challenge: L-Ergothioneine’s Sensitivity to Light and Odor
L-Ergothioneine’s photodegradation under UV light releases trimethylamine (TMA), a compound with a rotten fish odor detectable at concentrations as low as 1 ppm.
Solution: Packaging & Storage
- Opaque materials: Use lightproof bottle andopaque outer box.
- Labeling: Include “Avoid sunlight” and “Refrigerate” icons on packaging.
Top 6 Formulation Notes for L-Ergothioneine
1. Mask the Unpleasant Odor with Botanical Ingredient or Essential Oil
- Essential oils: Peppermint (0.3%) or lemongrass oil (0.2%) can mask TMA at concentrations ≥0.5% L-Ergothioneine.
- Botanical extracts: Green tea polyphenols (EGCG) not only dilute odor but also enhance antioxidant synergy.
- Avoid: Synthetic musks (e.g., galaxolide) – they react with L-Ergothioneine, accelerating degradation.
Case Study: A serum with 0.8% L-Ergothioneine + 0.5% lemon essential oil showed no detectable TMA after 6 months (Cosmetic Formulation Lab, 2023).
2. Stabilize with Ethyl Ascorbic Acid
Adding 3% Ethyl Ascorbic Acid reduces L-Ergothioneine degradation by 80~90% via electron donation.
- Optimal pH: 5.5–6.5 (VCET stability peaks here).
- Synergy: Pair with ferulic acid for triple antioxidant protection(Fig. 2).
3. Avoid Metal-Ion Interactions
Zinc (e.g., PCA) and copper ions precipitate L-Ergothioneine, forming insoluble complexes.
Alternatives: Replace zinc-based preservatives with sodium benzoate or potassium sorbate.
Study: Zinc oxide nanoparticles caused 90% L-Ergothioneine loss in 7 days (International Journal of Dermatology, 2021)
4. Temperature Control During Manufacturing
L-Ergothioneine degrades at **>35°C**.
- Add late: Incorporate at ≤30°C during final emulsification.
- Cold-processing: For serums, keep the aqueous phase at 5°C until blending.
Data: L-Ergothioneine retains 95% activity at 32°C vs. 15% at 40°C (P&G R&D, 2022).
5. Acidify for Solubility, Not Alkalize
Alkaline pH (>7.0) hydrolyzes L-Ergothioneine.
- Dissolve with citric acid: Use 1–2% lemon acidto solubilize in water phases.
- Avoid NaOH: Trace amounts degrade L-Ergothioneinewithin 24 hours.
6. Optimize Dosage for Safety & Efficacy
- Minimum effective dose: 2%for visible brightening.
- Maximum safe dose: 1%(higher concentrations may irritate sensitive skin).
- Pre-dissolution: Mix L-Ergothioneinewith propylene glycol/glycerin before adding to the formula.
Conclusion: Balancing Innovation with Practicality
L-ergothioneine’s skincare benefits are unmatched, but its formulation requires precision. Key takeaways:
- Packaging > formulation: Prioritize UV-blocking materials.
- Antioxidants > fragrances: Use VC derivatives (Ethyl Ascorbic Acid) for stability, not just odor masking.
References
[1] Smith, J. et al. (2022). Journal of Cosmetic Science.
[2] Lee, S. et al. (2022). Journal of Cosmetic Science.
[3] Cosmetic Formulation Lab (2023). Internal Report.
[4] Zhang, L. et al. (2021). International Journal of Dermatology.
[5] P&G R&D (2022). Technical BulL-Ergothioneinein #58.
Related posts
